Tenth District: Teen’s Lawsuit Against Homecoming Party Hosts for Alcohol-Related Injury Can Proceed

An appeals court ruled a case involving an intoxicated teen who obtained car keys after a dance can proceed.
In 2021, 17-year-old high school student Rachel Ohlin became intoxicated at a post-homecoming party and obtained keys to someone else’s automobile. Ohlin left the party and drove the vehicle into a guardrail, causing her to suffer permanent and substantial injuries.
Ohlin filed a negligence lawsuit in 2023 against the homeowner and party hosts, Amy Machol and her daughter Alexa, claiming they had a responsibility over her actions as social hosts. Ohlin also sued the store N. High Tobacco for Less and its owner, alleging the store sold alcohol to individuals under the age of 21 who attended the party and that those sales contributed to her injuries.
The Franklin County Common Pleas Court dismissed the lawsuit. Recently, the Tenth District Court of Appeals ruled the case could proceed, finding that the trial court dismissed the claims too early.
Drinking Led to Car Accident
According to briefs submitted for the case, Ohlin was invited in October 2021 to the Machols home for a homecoming after-party. She was provided alcohol by Amy Machol and her daughter, as well as nine other partygoers. Ohlin maintained that these other under-21 partygoers were sold alcohol by N. High Tobacco for Less.
Ohlin claimed that after becoming knowingly intoxicated, one of the other partygoers provided his friend’s car keys to Ohlin and allowed her to operate the vehicle. She crashed into a guardrail, wrecking the car and causing injuries that made her wheelchair-bound.
Trial Court Dismissed Claims
The trial court dismissed all claims without allowing a trial . The court issued a judgment on the pleadings in favor of the Machols and dismissed the claims against the store and its owner. Claims against other defendants were resolved. Ohlin appealed the dismissals to the Tenth District.
On appeal, Ohlin argued the trial court improperly dismissed her claims against the Machols as social hosts and that Ohio’s Dram Shop Act doesn’t shield the liquor permit holders from liability when alcohol is sold to minors.
Appeals Court Reviews Social-Host Liability
Writing for the Tenth District, Judge Shawn Dingus explained that Ohio law prohibits a person from furnishing alcohol to an underage individual. The court noted that a violation of the applicable statute can constitute “negligence per se," meaning the law itself establishes a social host duty and a breach of that duty.
While Ohlin voluntarily consumed alcohol and may be seen as fully responsible for any consequences, Judge Dingus wrote that “the likelihood of this voluntariness merely reinforces the importance of the duty itself.” Since it is likely that a teen at a party might drink alcohol, it is the duty of a homeowner to prevent it, he explained.
Judge Dingus emphasized that when reviewing a motion to dismiss, courts must assume the facts alleged in the complaint are true and draw reasonable inferences in favor of the plaintiff. Based on that standard, the appellate court determined that Ohlin’s allegations that the homeowners furnished alcohol to her while she was underage were sufficient to state a legal claim.
The court also concluded that questions regarding whether the alcohol provided at the party proximate caused Ohlin’s injuries involve factual issues that ordinarily should be decided later in the litigation process rather than at the pleading stage.
As a result, the Tenth District ruled that the trial court incorrectly dismissed the claims against the Machols.
Dram Shop Act Protected Alcohol Seller
The Tenth District reached a different conclusion regarding the claims against the store that sold the teens alcohol. The court explained that the Dram Shop Act, R.C. 4399.18, provides the exclusive civil remedy against liquor permit holders for injuries arising from the sale of alcohol. While Ohlin alleged that alcohol had been sold to underage individuals, the court found that her complaint didn’t satisfy the statutory requirements necessary for the store or its owner to be liable under the Dram Shop Act.
Because Ohio law limits when permit holders may be sued for alcohol-related injuries, the court concluded that the negligence claims against the store and its owner could not proceed.
The decision returned the case to the trial court for further proceedings on the remaining claims against the Machols.
Judges Laurel Beatty Blunt and Carly M. Edelstein joined Judge Dingus' opinion .
Ohlin v. Machol, 2026-Ohio-4118.
Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Communications for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.
Acrobat Reader is a trademark of Adobe Systems Incorporated.